Written by: Nick G. on 23 October 2026
(The system needs treatment. Supplied, AI generated)
Dr Helen Haines, the Independent MP for the federal seat of Indi, is a victim of the broken system of rural healthcare which she had fought to improve.
It has been revealed that Haines privately lobbied the prime minister for urgent rural health funding just five days before she is alleged to have been mowed down outside her electorate office by a man whose lawyer says is suffering from mental and chronic health conditions.
According to the ABC, “Ms Haines handed Anthony Albanese an annotated copy of the Forgotten Health Spend: A Report on the Expenditure Deficit in Rural Australia 2026 in a special crossbench catch-up with the prime minister last Wednesday to highlight a growing $2.7 billion expenditure gap between metropolitan and regional areas.”
Wangaratta local council health data shows 23.7 registered mental health clients per 1,000 residents, almost double the Victorian average of 11.9.
The gutting of mental health services
Federal Labor, which has embraced Liberal PM Scott Morrison’s scheme to bankrupt the nation by playing big boys with a handful of nuclear-powered submarines, has overseen cutbacks in rural mental health services.
Scientist Dr Ian Corbell told this morning’s AM radio program that has seen funding for mobile mental health treatment teams hollowed out since he worked in them in the 1990s.
He had warned in 2023 of a mental health crisis and further distressing incidents like the one in which two police officers had assaulted a naked and mentally disturbed woman in a street during daylight hours, spraying capsicum spray into her face and on her genitals, later boasting that they had emptied two canisters of spray on her.
Corbel expressed concern that police are not properly equipped to handle mental health crises and that their reactive, punitive approach would only exacerbate matters.
The situation in Australia has been allowed by government neglect and privatised services to mimic the US situation where the National Alliance on Mental Illness states that about “2 million times each year, people with mental illness are booked in our nation’s jails, often because communities rely on law enforcement to respond to mental health crises — and they lack the needed resources to truly support someone in crisis. It should not be the job of law enforcement to respond to health care crises, and people experiencing a mental health emergency deserve quick access to effective mental health care — just as people expect when experiencing physical health emergencies.”
McGorry denounces cutbacks
2010 Australian of the Year Professor Pat McGorry has been speaking out about the deliberate neglect of mental health services in Australia predicting the type of disasters such as the Bondi shopping centre and now the attack on Independent MP Helen Haines.
McGorry holds a highly critical view of the neglect of mental health services in Australia, characterizing the situation as a long-standing systemic failure that has been met with political complacency and, at times, deliberate misrepresentation of progress.
McGorry has argued that Australia's mental health system operates on a reactive "ambulance at the bottom of the cliff" model, where investment is disproportionately directed toward crisis support rather than early intervention. He has described the system as "Third World" and a "scandal," noting that the neglect is so severe that many mentally ill individuals end up in the prison system simply because there is nowhere else for them to go.
He points out the stark funding mismatch: the federal government invests roughly $4 billion to $4.8 billion annually in mental health care, compared to the massive $12.2 billion allocated over the next 30 years for the AUKUS subs. In the wider defence context, in the 2026-27 Budget, the Department of Defence was allocated $44.2 billion, with an additional $15.3 billion for capability investment.
McGorry's most scathing recent criticism targets the Victorian government's handling of mental health reform following the landmark Royal Commission. In a prominent op-ed, he accused the government of "mass gaslighting" by claiming progress while the system deteriorates.
In summary, McGorry views the neglect as a persistent policy choice characterized by chronic underfunding, a failure to implement early intervention, and a lack of political will to follow through on systemic reform, resulting in avoidable human suffering and social costs.
Some have suggested Australia's spending on mental health is relatively low compared to other high-income, OECD nations. A 2026 news release cites a Murdoch University study stating that "Australia spends substantially less per person on mental-health care compared with other high-income nations".
A German comparative report (citing OECD data accessed in 2023) lists Australia's direct per capita spending on mental health at US$288.30 for the 2020-21 period, compared to US$2,231.20 for the Netherlands.
The system needs treatment
Even if the tooth fairy could wave a magic wand over the empty heads in government and opposition benches and see a release of needed funding, the fundamental approach to mental health under capitalism will not improve.
The ethics of bourgeois psychology upon which mental health services rest, treats patients at the crisis stage. As McGorry said, it is the “ambulance at the bottom of the cliff” approach which has been allowed to develop through the absence of preventative approaches which could have prevented the reaching of the critical stages.
It deals with crises as the failings of the individual and as the personal problem of the individual, rather than as the failings of capitalist society and the social problems of the system as a whole.
We wish Dr Haines well in her recovery, but we do not wish the same for capitalism.
A system of socialist ethics guiding mental health services is one more reason for advancing to socialism.




